Moscow Demands NATO Return to Pre 1997 Borders Before Shenzhen Talks
Russia has demanded that NATO return to its pre 1997 borders during talks in Abu Dhabi, according to reports, a hardline position that will hang over the meeting between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on November 19.
The demand, which would require the alliance to roll back the enlargements that brought in Poland, the Baltic states, and much of eastern Europe, has been rejected by allied governments in the past. Its return to the negotiating table suggests Moscow is using the run up to the summit to set a maximalist opening position rather than to signal flexibility.
Diplomatic momentum, hard positions
Diplomatic momentum has been building ahead of the planned summit on November 19 in Shenzhen, with United States special envoy Jared Kushner continuing engagement in the lead up to the meeting. The Abu Dhabi talks, which have involved American and Russian officials, were meant to narrow differences on Ukraine, but the NATO demand shows how wide those differences remain.
For the United States and its allies, the pre 1997 demand is a non starter. It would undo three decades of alliance expansion and abandon countries that joined NATO precisely because they feared Russian pressure. For Moscow, the demand is a statement of principle: that the alliance expansion eastwards was a mistake that must be corrected.
What the summit can do
The Shenzhen meeting is the first three way summit of its kind, and it gives the three leaders a chance to state their positions directly. But a meeting cannot settle a question as fundamental as the shape of European security, and diplomats caution that the most realistic outcome is a clearer understanding of where each side stands.
That clarity has value. If the summit shows that Moscow will not move on NATO, then the United States and its allies will know that the Ukraine war will not end through a grand bargain, and they will have to plan accordingly. The demand may be a negotiating tactic, but it may also be the truth, and Thursday will help to tell which.

